A scorecard only matters if it changes who you buy from, how much and on what terms. Build it from receipts and inspections, and use it at the point of ordering.
Why most scorecards are ignored
Many companies have a supplier scorecard. It is often a spreadsheet updated once a year, filled with scores that are half memory and half opinion, presented in a review meeting and then forgotten. Suppliers know this, so the scorecard does not change how they behave.
A useful scorecard has two properties. Its scores come from records, not recollection, so nobody can argue about them. And it is used where buying decisions are made, so a poor score has consequences a supplier can feel.
Measure what you already record
If you buy through an ERP, you already have most of the data you need. Every purchase order has a promised date and quantity. Every receipt has an actual date, an actual quantity and, if you inspect incoming goods, a result. Every invoice has a price that can be compared with the order.
From those records you can measure:
- On-time delivery: share of receipts that arrived on or before the promised date.
- In-full delivery: share of order lines received in the ordered quantity.
- Quality: share of received quantity accepted at incoming inspection, from Sundial's Quality module.
- Price accuracy: share of invoices that matched the agreed price.
- Responsiveness: how quickly the supplier responds to requests for quotation.
Pick the few that matter most to your business. A scorecard with fifteen criteria is a scorecard nobody reads.
Weight the criteria honestly
Not every criterion matters equally, and the weighting should reflect what hurts you most. For a manufacturer whose line stops when material is late, on-time delivery may deserve the largest weight. For a business selling regulated products, quality may come first. For a distributor competing on price, price accuracy and cost matter more.
In Sundial, a supplier scorecard combines weighted criteria into a single score for each period, calculated from the transactions in that period. The formula is visible to everyone who uses it, which matters when a supplier asks how their score was worked out.
Turn scores into standings
A number on its own does not tell a buyer what to do. Map score ranges to standings with clear consequences, for example:
- Excellent: preferred supplier. First invitation for new RFQs; candidate for longer contracts.
- Good: normal business.
- Needs improvement: buyers see a warning when creating RFQs or purchase orders. A review meeting is scheduled.
- Poor: new purchase orders are blocked, or need senior approval, until the supplier improves.
Sundial can show a warning or block new RFQs and purchase orders based on the supplier's standing. That is what turns a scorecard from a report into a control.
Share the scorecard with the supplier
Suppliers cannot improve against a score they never see. Share the scorecard every quarter, with the underlying data: which deliveries were late, which lots failed inspection, which invoices did not match. Specific records lead to specific fixes; a general complaint leads to a general apology.
Be fair about your own part. If a delivery was late because your purchase order went out with too little lead time, that should not count against the supplier. Record the promised date the supplier actually agreed to, not the date you wished for.
Use scores in buying decisions
The scorecard should appear wherever a buyer chooses a supplier:
- When comparing supplier quotations, show each supplier's standing next to its price, so a cheaper offer from a poorly performing supplier is weighed properly.
- When allocating volume between two approved suppliers, shift share towards the better performer.
- When negotiating annual terms, bring the scorecard. It is the clearest evidence you have.
Combine scores with landed cost for the full picture: a supplier who is cheaper per unit but late and inconsistent often costs more once expediting, rework and stockouts are counted.
Keep it simple and keep it going
Start with three criteria, calculated monthly, for your most important suppliers. Review standings once a quarter. Add criteria only when a real problem demands it.
Data quality decides whether anyone believes the scores. Receipts must be posted on the day goods arrive, against the right purchase order line, or on-time figures will be wrong. Inspection results must be recorded for every lot you inspect, not only the failures. If a supplier challenges a score and the records do not support it, fix the recording habit before you defend the number.
We are designing Sundial so an AI agent can prepare each supplier's quarterly review pack from receipts, inspections and invoices, and draft the conversation points, with your buyers deciding what to send. To see scorecards on sample data, try the demo.





